Study ID | Study design | Intervention | Implementation | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Small sample size | Insufficient follow-up period | Lack of control group | High dropout rate | Representativeness of sample | Lack specificity | Inappropriate dose/ period | Low recruitment rate | |
(Burrows et al., 2023) | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(Nelson et al., 2018) | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(Fallahpour et al., 2020) | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(Cho & Sohng, 2014) | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ | ✔ | Ìý |
(Eaton et al., 2020) | ✔ | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ |
(Hayashi et al., 2017) | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ | ✔ |
(Gross et al., 2017) | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ |
(Reilly-Spong et al., 2015) | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(Jakubowski et al., 2020) | ✔ | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(Hudson et al., 2017) | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ |
(Sandys et al., 2022) | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý |
(Dawson, Tong, et al., 2021) | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(Ni et al., 2019) | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(Torabikhah et al., 2023) | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(Kargar Jahromi et al., 2015) | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(Li et al., 2014) | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(Duncanson et al., 2020) | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(Hernandez et al., 2018) | Ìý | ✔ | ✔ | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(Agarwal et al., 2023) | ✔ | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý |
(Flythe et al., 2020) | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(A. Hosseini et al., 2023) | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(TuroÅ„-SkrzypiÅ„ska et al., 2023) | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(Brys et al., 2021) | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(Hernandez et al., 2021) | ✔ | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(Torabikhah et al., 2023) | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
(Fakih El Khoury et al., 2020) | Ìý | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý | ✔ | Ìý |
(T. Hosseini et al., 2024) | ✔ | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý | Ìý |
Total | 10 (37.04%) | 5 (18.52%) | 6 (22.22%) | 1 (3.70%) | 13 (48.15%) | 1 (3.70%) | 5 (18.52%) | 4 (14.81%) |